Suffolk County wants judge to toss $112M judgment over immigration detainees: court docs

Suffolk County is attempting to overturn a $112 million class-action payout to immigration detainees who were held beyond legal limits, claiming the jury’s decision was “fundamentally flawed.” The case originated from the county’s policy of honoring federal ICE detainer requests, deemed unlawful in 2018. County officials argue the $37 million award for the class, and the subsequent $75 million for loss of liberty—amounting to roughly $115,000 per detainee—are excessive and should be reconsidered. They cite the lead plaintiff’s testimony, focusing on feelings of sadness and confusion, and claim erroneous jury instructions contributed to the high award.

LatinoJustice PRLDEF, the advocacy group representing the detainees, contends the county’s expenses are self-inflicted and accuses them of delaying the case with “meritless” motions to avoid responsibility. The county has already spent $650,000 on a surety bond and over $2 million on legal fees.

This legal battle occurs amidst increased scrutiny of Suffolk County’s collaboration with federal immigration enforcement, including a recent ruling finding both the county and federal officials operated “inhumanely and unlawfully” in detainment conditions. Judge William Kuntz II is expected to issue a written decision next month.

(Source：New York Post)